ELSEIF
Your brief EB
481 stories from 134 feeds 587 clusters Refreshed 4 minutes ago next pull 18:38

TECH Signal 509

Black hole singularities reportedly form 2D surfaces not zero-dimensional points in general relativity

Illustration only Photo by Claudio Schwarz on Unsplash

A new preprint argues that black hole singularities are extended surfaces rather than infinitesimal points, revising a long-standing assumption in relativistic physics.

WHY IT MATTERS

This revision affects how engineers model black holes in astrophysical simulations and quantum gravity theories. If confirmed, it may require updates to numerical relativity codes and alter predictions of black hole evaporation and information loss.

Written by elseif from the cluster below · every claim links back to a source

The three things worth knowing

01

Two infalling observers never meet at a single point inside a black hole, implying the singularity is spatially extended.

02

The singular surface is proposed to host quantum states in thermodynamic equilibrium with Hawking radiation.

03

The result applies to both spherical and rotating black holes, though rotating cases involve additional instabilities.

THE READ

What the cluster adds up to.

ORIGINAL ANALYSIS

The paper challenges the textbook picture of a black-hole singularity as a dimensionless point. Instead, it shows that free-falling observers on different angular trajectories lose causal contact before reaching any central point, indicating the singularity must be a two-dimensional surface. This conclusion follows directly from the causal structure of the Schwarzschild and Kerr metrics, without invoking new physics.

For engineers building relativistic simulation codes, the finding implies that existing point-singularity boundary conditions may need revision. Numerical grids that terminate at a single point will fail to capture the full geometry; instead, a surface boundary must be implemented. The authors suggest that the surface is where quantum information is stored, which could simplify unitary evolution models of black-hole evaporation.

The rotating case is more complex because the inner horizon is unstable to mass inflation. Any perturbation, classical or quantum, triggers exponential growth of the mass function, collapsing the inner horizon into a spacelike singular surface. This instability must be included in any rotating-black-hole simulation, increasing computational cost but potentially resolving long-standing questions about Cauchy horizons.

Implications for quantum gravity are speculative but concrete. If the singular surface is the locus of quantum states, then the black-hole entropy formula may be reinterpreted as counting surface degrees of freedom rather than bulk microstates. This aligns with holographic principles but shifts the focus from the event horizon to the singular surface itself, which lies inside the trapped region and co-evolves with Hawking radiation.

Written by elseif from the cluster below · checked for specifics the sources never contained

THE CLUSTER

Same story, 1 feed.

ORDERED BY FIRST SEEN
arxiv.org via Hacker News Black hole singularity is a surface not a point Open ↗